02 September 2009

Giambelli Is Done and Gone


Giambelli 50th Ristaronte, an old-school Italian mainstay in Midtown East, has closed its doors for good.

I passed by the unassuming red-brick building yesterday. I peered in the window, because I had long been considering the place as the subject of a "Who Goes There?" column. Instead, I found a sign saying: "To all our wonderful customers. Sorry we are closing our doors due to take over by the MTA. Thank you!"

I walked across the street to the Maloney & Porcelli steakhouse and the maitre d' confirmed that Giambelli's was gone for good, and had closed a month and a half ago. (I looked around the web, but haven't seen any news coverage of this). "It's a shame," he said. "We complimented each other for years. When people wanted Italian, I'd send them over there. When they wanted a steak, he'd send them here." He said the MTA seized the property through Eminent Domain for an upcoming construction project.

Giambelli was founded by Francesco ''Frank'' Giambelli, who died in 2006 at the age of 90. He was born in 1915 in Voghera, outside Milan, Italy. Frank came to the U.S. in 1954 to open Giambelli's Ristorante, originally located on Madison Avenue and 37th Street; it relocated to 50th and Madison Avenue in 1960. In 1995, during Pope John Paul II's trip to New York, Giambelli's served the Pope and fifty Cardinals at the Cardinal's residence. The cuisine was northern Italian. The interior had off-white walls, light brown banquettes, picturesque paintings, Classical bronze statues, and riotously colorful floral arrangements. One account said that a long-stemmed rose was given to each female guest.

26 comments:

  1. It's true. I got a lovely salmon-colored rose. The food was pricey buut good and the service impeccable.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I will also miss Giambelli 50th it was always the best and a most comfortable dining experience, my former husband had been a customer for probably over 30 of its 50 yr history and was fond of Frank and his family . You will be sorely missed.

    ReplyDelete
  3. My husband and I had our first date at Giambelli's! That was 6 years ago! On a whim, I asked my husband to take me to dinner at Giambelli's in June, and that night we found out about their upcoming closing! I took 2 plates ;o) We miss Mrs. Giambelli and the Gondellas! MMMMMMMMM...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Frank would not let me pay for dinner for my lovely girlfriend and I after he invited us to his restaurant. A wonderful man, he and Giambelli's will be missed.

    ReplyDelete
  5. All the way from Georgia, stumbled in by accident. Honestly great food and kind-hearted accommodating people. Real Italian, and yes, I have been to Italy. It's so sad. It was real New York too. Manhattan is a poorer place.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was a loyal customer for 35 years.My girlfriend andI will miss the food and seamless service.We always felt more than welcome.Giambelli's closing is like the loss of a friend. Bill Ruzzo

    ReplyDelete
  7. Diane and family11/05/2009 12:47 PM

    So so sad....only found out when recommending Giambellli's to a friend. My Mother's favorite spot in the city.....went there with her and my sisters for years (back as far as 1985......starting going with my husband ten years ago. We were saddened when Mr. Giambelli passed....now this....I will miss my rose!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Mary and Bill Kennedy12/16/2009 4:20 PM

    Yesterday was one of the saddest days for my husband and me. We walked by Giambelli's and could not believe our eyes. Here are the special family events we celebrated there: my husband's
    40th, my 40th, our daughter's "sweet 16," my husband's 50th, multiple business parties, many wonderful holiday dinners with my parents, our children, AND our 3 granddaughters, who just loved going there. Mr. and Mrs. Giambelli were so lovely! We feel like a wonderful piece of our lives has been grabbed, and we are sad.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Jeff Nickell12/26/2009 7:07 AM

    My Mom took me to Giambelli's when I turned 16. Mr. Giambelli came by our table and told me he would buy me a glass of champagne when I turned 21. I was from South Florida and I just assumed all New York restaurants were like this -- family oriented, genuine, where the owner came by your table to tell you he appreciated you choosing his place for a special event -- but I've never found anything like it in the city ever since. About 9 years later when I was ready to marry the girl of my dreams we got engaged at Giambelli's and Mr. Giambelli came to our table and bought us a bottle of champagne. With the closing of this restaurant something has been lost -- I will miss this place and what it represented to me.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Tonight, while visiting the area to see the tree, I made the sad discovery that my favorite little Italian restaurant was not only closed but completely abandoned! Not a trace of the warmth and distinguished restaurant that my family and friends often visited. Yes...NYC is turning into a slick of chain restaurants, glossy designer store fronts, and bling. I long for the NYC that hosts restaurants like Giambelli that treat their customers with care and serve authentic fine food! We will miss the restaurant, but we have great memories!

    ReplyDelete
  11. i am truly heartbroken.....i was sending a link to a friend's parents visiting new york for the first time when i stumbled across your website. my father was closely acquainted with the charming and always gracious frank giambelli. my family spent many wonderful evenings there. mr g even named a dish after my father! one of my fondest memories is a dinner there in 1995 with my german boyfriend, new to the states. we ordered strawberries with canoli cream and mr g went up to his own apartment upstairs for the strawberries since the kitchen was out of them.......boy, was jen's impressed. he broke up with me shortly after that, but that's another story....lol....but wow, no giambelli....this is very, very, upsetting. the destruction of ny landmarks has unfortunately become all too common in recent years. i was quite upset by the demise of one of my favorite west village restaurants about 6 months ago-the minetta tavern on minetta lane. sad, sad, sad. but i do thank you for your blog and moving tribute to what in my opinion was the best restaurant in new york owned by one of new york's finest gentlemen.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Became accainted with Mr. Giambelli's Mercurio resturant on 53rd and 6th in the late sixties. Could only afford annual or semi annual vists. MoMA took over that building around 1980 and forced him out - took the china to 50th - building remained vacant for a decade. Food and service were actually more special there. Finally met him in 2003 at my stepmother's 75th. Best of luck to his Familly and staff.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I discoverd this gem about 10 years ago when I was searching for a restaurant that served Canneloni, my favorite Italian dish - perhaps my favorite dish of any cuisine. The Canneloni here was the best I've ever had - so creamy and light though very rich at the same time. So sad that this restaurant will no longer fill my Canneloni cravings. I haven't found another restaurant that serves this dish snd I can't imagine I'll find one that makes such a delicious version. With the closing of this restaurant and the demise of the German cart on 54th and Fifth this past year due to the death of one of the brothers who ran the cart my favorite midtown eateries are dwindling. Boo to the MTA!

    ReplyDelete
  14. We were shocked to see that Giambelli 50th is shuttered! I have been going there for 40+ years! Just walked by last week while visiting the city, and couldn't believe my eyes!! What a shame!!

    ReplyDelete
  15. I retired in 1976 and my office was a short walk. I remember the fine food and service. I remember Frank by the bar cleaning truffles. He would come over to my table with warm greetings and food suggestions.
    I lost a button on my top coat and the check room lady sewed it back on.
    At the end of my meals he asked where I was going and offered me his car and driver to take me too my next spot.
    Many fond memories and a sad loss for food lovers

    ReplyDelete
  16. WHAT?
    oh my gosh
    NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
    I just found out today
    was going to NYC next week
    THIS IS TRAGIC :(

    ---a Canadian Fan :)

    ReplyDelete
  17. Does anyone know where the great staff went to? The maitre'd, the waiters, etc. Are they possibly working at another New York Italian restaurant.
    Missing Giambelli.
    New Yorker transplanted to DC

    ReplyDelete
  18. Very sad! Visited there every time I got to NYC! Outstanding food and service! And zabione tableside; no other place that I know did that- and not with pasteurized eggs like CA requires. What a shame

    ReplyDelete
  19. So sad it closed
    I know it's been years. but this was my GO TO ITALIAN place in NYC
    Staff always remembered my name. treated everyone as equals. sad sad sad. I will miss it

    ReplyDelete
  20. I'm a Bostonian who considered Giambelli's home away from home.Called one night after a very late Broadway show and Frank said get here when you can Mr. Toomey, I'll keep the kitchen open. A piece of me has passed !

    Ed Toomey


    ReplyDelete
  21. I remember dining at Giambelli's with my mom and her boss in the mid to late 60's. I was about nine years old. My sister and I had a tour of the kitchen, and yes, we each received a rose. I believe the Maitre'd name was Gianni. We also were fortunate to have dined at Lutece and the Leopard restaurants. A different era......thank you Phelps-Dodge expense account! Sublime childhood memories!!!

    ReplyDelete
  22. ‘Peniche’ in New Zealand says...
    ..we used to dine at Giambelli regularly in the mid 1970s. One evening we arrived to find the restaurant gutted for renovation.
    As we turned to leave a diminutive, but immaculate gentleman on the sidewalk introduced himself. 'I am Francesco Giambell...please!' and indicated a stretch Cadillac, sat beside the driver and took us to Mercurios. He asked my name, led us into the restaurant clapping his hands announcing 'Champagne for Senor Peniche and his party', saw that we were well seated and returned to Giambelli for more customers. I have thereafter been called 'Peniche' by my friends although the name only vaguely resembles my own.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I had one of the most amazing nights of my life at Giambelli's restaurant. 2 friends and I went there after a night of theater when nothing else seemed to be open. From the moment we walked in, we were treated like royalty: not just roses at our table, but champagne, a special dinner created just for us by the chef, who came out to ask us what we liked to eat. Amazing dish after dish came out of the kitchen until we were full to bursting. Then a marvelous dessert and a request to join Mr. Giambelli himself at the bar, where he served us chocolate covered strawberries and more champagne. My friends and I were bewildered but thrilled. We never saw a bill for the amazing dinner. Finally, we said we had to leave since we had work the next day and they called a taxi for us. As I was getting into the cab, Mr. Giambelli said "Miss Najimy, you must come again and bring more of your charming friends!"

    It took about 4 minutes before I realized - he thought I was Kathy Najimy, who was starring in "Sister Act" at the time! I don't really think I look much like her, but he sure did.

    What a gentleman!! I'm so sorry the place is gone.

    ReplyDelete
  24. It was the best italian place in New York! We are going to miss it.. Mr Giambelli used to write down the childrens birthdate so he could treat them to something special for their 18 birthday! Its going to be missed! A NY landmark!
    Fernanda fron Mexico

    ReplyDelete
  25. We went there for my dad's 50th birthday 28 years ago. I remember he wanted to go there. It was a special evening. Tonight we were reminiscing about when we used to make zabaglione at home, and then I remembered having it at Giambelli 50th. We're free calling that beautiful dinner tonight, and then were sorry to see that it's gone now.

    ReplyDelete
  26. This restaurant gave me "my fairytale Christmas visit" in 1967! We were expecting our first child in February, so we decided to spend a weekend in NYC before the big event to enjoy the Christmas windows and a play. We picked Giambelli 50th for dinner and while we were there it started to rain heavily. We were seated near the kitchen and had been conversing with the owners as we enjoyed our wonderful meal. As we were getting ready to head out into the the cold sleety night to hail a cab, the owner said "wait" ... "my wife is leaving with our driver and they will drop you off at the play location." What a "magical Christmas miracle" to have happen to a young couple from Saratoga Springs, NY. We have never forgotten ... even after 52 years! We were hoping to return this Dec. (while visiting NYC from our current home in Las Vegas, NV) and we are very sad to hear the news of the closing! May God Bless the Giambelli family and staff! 💕

    ReplyDelete

Sorry. This blog DOES NOT accept Anonymous comments. I also reserve the right to not post abusive or offensive comments, or anything that contains the phrase "a real New Yorker."